Xero or FreeAgent? Choosing the Right Accounting Software for Your Business

Every few weeks we meet a business owner whose accounting software was chosen quickly, based on whatever a friend used or whatever came up first in a search. Often it was never quite right for the business in the first place, and switching later means months of tidying up historic data that could have been straightforward from day one. So, it is worth thinking this through properly before you commit.

Why the Software Decision Matters More Than It Used To

Software providers like to make it look like anyone can log in and run their own books from day one. There is a real difference between data entry and bookkeeping, though a lot of business owners see the two as the same thing. Data entry is putting the numbers in. Bookkeeping, which is what our trained team does, is knowing what those numbers mean, including spotting something like a mobile phone contract sitting in your own name rather than the company’s, which can quietly create a personal tax bill.

The stakes have also risen too. Since April 2026, self-employed people and landlords with income over £50,000 must keep digital records and file quarterly under Making Tax Digital, a threshold falling to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028. VAT registered businesses have needed compatible software for years already, and getting the setup right from the outset matters, since errors from a poor start are hard to unpick.

We have chosen to specialise rather than spread ourselves thin. Our whole team holds Xero adviser certifications, and Xero is the platform we use with almost all our clients. We are also glad to work with FreeAgent, which is not something we can say for every platform on the market. This is our honest view of what each does well and which type of business each one suits.

Xero: What It Does Well and Who It Suits

Xero is the platform we use with most of our clients. The interface is clean, bank feed reconciliation is fast once set up properly, and the app ecosystem is the largest of the platforms we work with by a wide margin, so your accounting system can sit at the centre of the business rather than being a closed box. If you need stock management, a CRM connection, e-commerce integration, or industry specific software, there is a good chance Xero already has an app for it. We use Apron alongside it for all our clients, sole traders, property owners, and limited companies alike, which shows how well the wider ecosystem hangs together in practice.

Payroll is one area where we go outside Xero’s own tools, using BrightPay instead for its flexibility, its handling of more complex payroll situations, and its online portal for clients and employees, not a criticism of Xero’s own payroll, simply the combination that works best for us.

Xero also handles multi-currency well and scales comfortably as a business grows, flexing to handle more complicated situations such as multiple divisions or locations, running more than one sole trade, a mix of sole trade and property income, or jointly owned properties, using tracking codes to keep everything properly separated. Reports can be customised too, with analytics tools that look at performance and cash flow beyond a basic profit and loss. For a very simple sole trader, some of that will not be needed straight away, but for anyone expecting to grow, having it already built in saves time later.

FreeAgent: What It Does Well and Who It Suits

We are happy to work with FreeAgent, which is not something we can say for every platform out there. We think it is often overlooked, and it can suit sole traders, freelancers, and small limited companies with straightforward affairs. Like Xero, it can handle stock and multi-currency banking, so those are not the limiting factors people sometimes assume, and the simple interface makes everyday tasks like invoicing straightforward for clients while we handle the bookkeeping properly behind it. If you bank with NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank, or Mettle, FreeAgent may be included free as part of your business banking, a meaningful saving on paying a subscription elsewhere.

FreeAgent also has a product built specifically for landlords, letting us allocate rental income and expenses property by property, including where a property is jointly owned, and keep that reporting cleanly separated from the rest of a client’s affairs. As a business becomes genuinely more complex, several income streams, more complex reporting, or more detailed payroll needs, a platform like Xero tends to fit better. Some sole traders and small limited companies never reach that point, and FreeAgent suits them well for as long as they trade.

Digital Record Keeping: What You Actually Need

Both platforms are recognised by HMRC as MTD compatible for VAT and Income Tax, keeping the required digital records and submitting returns directly to HMRC rather than you typing figures into HMRC’s own portal, which no longer satisfies the rules for most businesses in scope.

Bridging software is an option, which connects a spreadsheet or other non-MTD-compatible system to HMRC without moving to a full cloud platform. Unless your business genuinely needs specialist software a mainstream platform cannot offer, bridging software is usually an unnecessary extra step that costs more over time. Compatibility itself is not the differentiator between Xero and FreeAgent, both do the job HMRC requires, so the decision comes down to which platform genuinely suits how your business operates. Our Making Tax Digital blog covers the wider rules in more detail if that would help.

The Questions to Ask Before You Choose

Before committing to a platform, it is worth working through a few questions properly rather than guessing:

1. Does your business have straightforward affairs, or are you expecting growth, additional income streams, or more complex reporting soon?
2. Do you need to keep multiple sole trades, or a mix of trading and property income, cleanly separated?
3. How much do you rely on detailed, customisable reporting and analytics to run the business day to day?
4. Do you want your accounting software to connect with a wide range of other business apps, such as stock, CRM, or e-commerce tools?
5. Which bank do you use, and does your business banking already include free software?

Answering these honestly, rather than picking whatever is advertised most heavily this month, will save a switching headache later. Accountants tend to have a preferred system of their own and are usually well placed to talk through the genuine pros and cons rather than just the marketing. If you have the flexibility to choose your accountant before committing to software, letting their preferred system guide the decision can make your life easier.

The Role Your Accountant Plays in Making the Software Work

Software on its own does not produce good numbers. The right platform set up badly, with the wrong VAT codes, an incomplete chart of accounts, or bank feeds that have never been properly reconciled, causes just as many problems as the wrong platform altogether. This is the same gap between data entry and bookkeeping mentioned earlier: entering a transaction is not the same as knowing it has been treated correctly or spotting a tax consequence you were not expecting. Our Good Bookkeeping blog covers this in more depth.

This raises a fair question we think about often: should an accountant steer clients toward the system they know best, or let the client’s own needs lead? It is not just theoretical for us. We worked only with Xero for years, and it was client need, not vendor preference, that led us to start supporting FreeAgent too. Going deep on one or two systems gives us a better understanding of how each can handle non-standard issues, and more experience of how similar businesses use it, but that depth needs to serve the business in front of us, not just what is easiest for the firm. We do not think there is one right answer, only that it is good to be upfront about the tension.

If your current software is not working for you, switching is more straightforward than most people expect. We use an app called Movemybooks to manage the migration, taking care of much of the manual work involved, so it is worth a conversation rather than something to put off.

Talk to Us Before You Commit

Getting the software choice right the first time saves a lot of time later, and time is worth as much as any subscription cost. If you are choosing software for the first time or wondering whether what you are on is still the right fit, get in touch and we will talk it through properly.

We will only use your details to send you this series and occasional updates from Composure Accounting. You can unsubscribe at any time. For more information see our Privacy Policy.